What scarf does Dakota Johnson wear?
A knit bandana rather than a blanket scarf — a small knitted triangle tied at the neck. It gives the warmth of wool at the throat without the bulk of a large wrap under a coat.
The piece is a knitted bandana, and the reason it is worth noticing is that it solves a specific problem with the blanket scarf it replaces.
The problem with a big scarf under a coat. A blanket scarf is warm because it is large, and large is exactly what you cannot accommodate inside a fitted coat. It bunches at the collar, pushes the lapels open, and most people end up taking it off indoors and carrying it. A small knitted triangle sits flat against the throat, fits under any collar, and stays on.
Where the warmth actually comes from. Less from the wool than from the gap it closes. An open collar vents warm air upward every time you move, and a coat insulates only as well as its weakest opening. Shut that gap and the whole coat feels warmer, which is why something this small changes more than its size suggests. You do not need volume. You need the gap closed.
What to look for. A wool or merino blend rather than acrylic — acrylic at the neck pills where you can see it, and it is warm for about three weeks. Check it ties: some knitted bandanas are shaped triangles with short ends that will not knot properly, and a scarf you cannot tie at the throat ends up decorative rather than warm.